Compare puppy buying providers.

Preferable Pups has the best plan for matching you with the puppy who best fits your home and lifestyle. Other companies’ puppy plans are complicated and time-consuming. Our no-nonsense, quick application process lets you begin your journey with your new puppy successfully.

Compare Preferable Pups

What to consider when buying a puppy

Do they sell online?

Do they sell online?

We discourage all puppy buyers from purchasing puppies online. Typically, when you have to check out online, this either is a puppy mill or a scam.

Breeder Standards

Breeder Standards

Preferable Pups set the standard for dog breeders. They must adhere to strict breeding guidelines to protect your puppy from being bred improperly.

Health Check

Puppy Health

Work with a puppy matching service instead of a puppy broker. Your pup should receive a thorough health exam from a third-party licensed veterinarian. This prevents naughty brokers from lying on the health reports.

Breeds

Breeds

Look closely at the breeds available, and insist on direct communication with the breeder you work with. We do this on your behalf!

Who is the safest company to buy a puppy from?

Use our puppy finder chart to decide for yourself! See how Preferable Pups stacks up against PuppySpot, Premier Pups, and BackYard Breeders.

Scroll to compare

Preferable Pups
Puppy Spot
Premier Pups
Greeenfield Puppies
Puppies Health

Third Party Proof Of health?

Yes
No
No
No

Reputation

Amazing

Negative

Very Bad

Very Bad

Breeder Verification

Difficult to pass

Easy to pass

No breeder verification

No breeder verification

Red Flags

Puppy Broker?

No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Customer Verification

No
No
No
Yes

Hide breeders Info

No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Intrusive Sales Approach

No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Sells Puppies Online

No
Yes
Yes
Yes

Breeder Allows You To Pick The Vet

Yes
No
No
No

Proof Of Breeding Grounds?

Yes
No
No
No

They Place Discounts On Puppies

No
Yes
Yes
Yes